The Art of Strategic Discounting

Published: Jan 24, 2019
Modified: Mar 24, 2020

In today’s erratic economy, the key to growing your business involves activating dormant customers by using strategic discounts. By “dormant,” I mean customers who are interested in your product or service, but have refrained from purchasing due to price.

The “art of discounting” involves offering lower prices to attract new, budget-conscious customers in a manner that minimizes the possibility of your current buyers (who are paying full price) taking advantage of these price breaks. In the best-case scenario, all current customers continue to pay full price and the discounts generate pure incremental profits. However, it’s more likely that some existing patrons will end up buying at the lower price. Thus, for a discount to be successful, profits from new customers must be greater than the margins lost from current buyers.

The following strategies will help you implement a strategic discounting initiative:

  • Sell through discount channels. A recent Wall Street Journal article notes the trend of upscale retailers seeking growth from outlet stores that target budget-conscious customers.*  Outlets have been a long-time strategy for upscale retailers such as Saks (SKS) and Nordstrom (JWN), which respectively operate Off 5th and Nordstrom Rack stores. This year Bloomingdale’s, Lord & Taylor, and Neiman Marcus will open new discount-oriented stores. Because outlets are generally not located in major metropolitan areas, they target different geographic customers. They also provide significant hurdles for current patrons to jump over—a long drive coupled with a limited selection—in order to reap discounts. In a similar vein, Morton’s (M8G) is promoting $5 bar bites that are offered only in the steakhouse’s bar areas.

    While not all companies can open up a new outlet, they can sell their products (and services) through distribution channels that target price sensitive customers in a manner that reduces the chances of cannibalization (current customers buying at a discount). High-end brands such as Starbucks (SBUX), Hyatt Hotels (H), and Godiva have sold discount gift cards through Costco, for instance.
  • Create a discount brand. It’s common for companies to create a new brand to serve a price sensitive audience. Sprint (S), for example, operates the prepaid cellular provider Boost Mobile. Boost’s $60 unlimited Blackberry package (talk, text, Web, e-mail) is considerably lower-priced than the $99.99 “Simply Everything” plan offered under the Sprint Brand which provides the same unlimited features. And while companies can’t start a new brand overnight, they can sell their products at a discount via private labels. Just last week, Sprint announced a $300 million deal to provide service for Cricket, the discount cellular company. To protect their brand, many manufacturing companies don’t want the public to know that they are selling discounted products. With the right confidentiality contract in place, who manufactures house-brand products can remain a closely guarded secret. The Private Label Manufacturers Association estimates that 65% of all food and beverage companies, including Sara Lee (SLE), Hormel (HRL), Bird’s Eye, and Del Monte (DLM), are involved in private label manufacturing.**
  • Use tried-and-true tactics such as coupons, sales, and promotions. While these strategies are commonly used, they often are not implemented correctly. Instead of viewing these discounts as a way to “move merchandise,” think of these techniques as avenues to activate price sensitive shoppers while keeping your current base paying full price. This involves creating hurdles (such as early morning sales on off-peak days, making customers clip and redeem coupons, etc.) that allow budget-minded customers to credibly raise their hands to say, “Price is important to me.”

It’s understandably stressful if a company loses, say, 15% of its business. In these situations, it’s common to take a “slash-prices-and-hope-for-the-best” stance. I prefer to focus on the fact that 85% of customers are still paying full price. The art of discounting involves maintaining current prices and implementing pricing strategies to activate dormant customers with low price options.

*Rachel Dodes, “Tony Retailers Hope Outlets Fuel Sales,” Wall Street Journal, August 9, 2010.
** Sonia Reyes, “Saving Private Labels,” Brandweek, May 8, 2006.