Workforce Growth Averages 5.9%, Annual AMA Survey Finds

Downsizing Declines as Leading Firms Emphasize Work vs. Jobs— Successful Firms Concurrently Create and Eliminate Jobs

NEW YORK, October 25, 2000—Major U.S. companies grew their workforces by an average annual rate of 5.9% despite higher turnover and a daunting lack of skilled workers, according to the American Management Association’s (AMA) yearly Staffing and Structure Survey, released today.

The 5.9% growth rate for the twelve months ending in June 2000 marks an increase from 5.0% in the previous twelve months. Turnover rates averaged 19%, up from 16.9%, and 76% of surveyed human resources managers said that skilled manpower was “scarce,” significantly higher than 66% in 1999 and 52% in 1997.

Even in this tight employment marketplace, more than three-quarters (77.8%) of the 1,441 surveyed firms created new jobs over the year while only 48.2% reported job cuts, slightly down from the previous 49.6%. Thirty-six percent reported concurrent hiring and firing, the highest level in the survey’s thirteen-year history, and actual “downsizing”ßdefined as a net decline in the total workforce—dipped to 21.2% from the previous year’s 24.1%.

“Companies have learned that downsizing and job cuts by themselves don’t automatically increase profitability,” said Eric Rolfe Greenberg, AMA’s director of management studies. “Instead, management is focusing on the work that adds value and creates a competitive advantage in the marketplace, not solely on the number of jobs added or eliminated. Companies that have consistently hired AND fired since 1995 have outperformed all others, including those who created new jobs but eliminated none over the same period.”

Fewer than half of companies reporting job elimination actually downsized (40%). In fact, hiring far outweighed firing in respondent firms. As a group, respondent companies created four new jobs for every one they cut in the twelve month surveyed period. Additionally, half (50%) the surveyed companies plan job creation within the next year, up from 48.2%, while only 20.5% anticipate job cuts in the same period.

“We have found that in both the short-term and the long-term, growing companies tend to outperform downsized firms, especially in such areas as employee morale and turnover rates,” stated Ellen Bayer, Global Human Resource Practice Leader for the AMA. “Flexibility and agility in staffing combined with an increased investment in training enhance the work environment and also improve corporate performance. Furthermore, 54% of companies that increased their training activities over the past year reported profit improvement, compared with 36% of all others,” added Bayer.

To view a comprehensive summary of the 2000 AMA Staffing & Structure Survey results visit the AMA research site at: http://www.amanet.org/research.

Note to editors: For more information regarding this survey or other AMA research please contact Eric Greenberg, AMA’s Director of Management Studies at 212-903-8052 or egreenberg@amanet.org.

About AMA
American Management Association (AMA) is the world’s leading membership-based management development organization. AMA offers a full range of business education and management development programs for individuals and organizations in Europe, the Americas and Asia. More than 700,000 AMA customers and members a year, including 488 out of the Fortune 500 companies, learn superior business skills and best management practices through a variety of seminars, conferences and special events, e-learning courses, assessments and customized learning solutions, publications, on-line resources and through interaction with AMA’s faculty of top practitioners.

back to top.

American Management Association © Copyright 1997-